Dolly and her son moved back home to Whitfield, Rhode Island for the summer to help out her dad and her brother save the family home. Working at the family fish shop while problem solving needing a new roof and not having the funds to get one, she runs into local scion Stewart Whitfield with a flat tire. At the end of a messy, very public break-up, Stewart is having a really bad week. A picture of an attractive young woman changing his tire is not what his reputation needs, so when it comes out in the paper the paper prints that he was teaching her instead of the other way around. Stewart tracks Dolly down to apologize and ends up with a paid for fake girlfriend. This sounds like a terrible idea to Dolly but when he offers to pay for her new roof she figures why not? As they get to know each other what was once fake starts to feel very real.
I eagerly wait for Annabel Monaghan’s book to come out every year. She is one of a handful of author’s that I can always count on to write a great story, create wonderfully real characters, and to know I’m going to enjoy practically every word that’s written. This book delivered on all three of those things. Their opposites attract/fake boyfriend-girlfriend tropes worked, although there were some silly, totally saw it coming story lines. I enjoyed the fact that Dolly was level headed and so real, and that Stewart was a workaholic who excelled at business but not at changing a tire. Their journey towards love was sweet and heart-breaking at the same time. I wasn’t sure when the shoe was going to drop on their fake scheme and it kept me reading every chapter!
Something else this author excels at is writing great familial relationships. Dolly’s dad was just wonderful and his sense of humor and dad advice were great additions to round out the story about her situation at home. Her son’s backstory held all of the drama of youth, but gave Dolly some great moments as a mother. She was such a well-rounded character.
If you love love, family relationships, and a little drama, then you should pick up this book and give it a go. I was not disappointed one bit and am not looking forward to next year when this author will release her next book.
I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review and it was honest.
Click this link to purchase this book!* Dolly All The Time
Copyright 2026 The Reading Chick All Rights Reserved
*Amazon Associate- if you purchase this book through the above link I’ll receive a small stipend.













You must be logged in to post a comment.